ISSUE NO. 2 · THE THANKSGIVING EDITION · NOVEMBER 2026

IN THIS ISSUE
① XOXO, Marco
② Fuck with the classics?
③ A word from our sponsor
④ Thanksgiving hats
⑤ Leftovers
⑥ SPORTS!
⑦ Barbaras Say What?
⑧ From the archives
① XOXO, MARCO
Gobble Gobble my Barbaras
I have a confession, don’t hate me…Thanksgiving is my least favorite holiday. (GAY GASP, you dramatically toss the turkey across the room) I know, I know, it’s controversial, you didn’t need to throw the turkey, Barbara.
Forgive me, I am but Wednesday Addams in the 1993 movie “Addams Family Values” where she burns the entire “First Thanksgiving” play down to the ground live on stage with her cute Jewish lover. The parallels are crazy here. While I have no plans of burning Thanksgiving to the ground with my cute Jewish husband, Danny, Thanksgiving can sometimes feel like you’re mentally on fire as you navigate a giant dead bird that will inevitably be dry-as-hell, your weird relative who still calls your husband “your friend,” or the feeling of dread and disappointment as you need to be rolled to the car because you ate your weight in stuffing.
Stress. I feel stress when it comes to Thanksgiving. But why don’t I feel that same stress 29 days after Thanksgiving when it’s Christmas? Why am I running around Christmas morning like a sassy gay George Bailey from “It’s a Wonderful Life,” giggling and singing? What is it about Thanksgiving that makes it so stressful, and how can we better prepare ourselves so this shitshow doesn’t end with us crying in our childhood bedroom because our mother made a weird comment about our appearance and we spent days cooking and everyone just complained and didn’t say thank you once!?!?! Breathe, Barbara! BREATHE! Hopefully we can combat some of this anxiety in this Gooseletter.
The happiest of my Thanksgiving memories are because of my Auntie Gracie, who would host Thanksgiving every year. Auntie Gracie lived on the south side of Chicago near Midway Airport in the house my mother and her siblings grew up in with my Italian grandparents. Auntie Gracie was the star of Thanksgiving, and like any true star, she had giant red hair. Red hair that was always styled like some giant bird doing a mating dance on her head. I applaud Auntie Gracie. She always took risks when it came to her hair, and I like to think that I got some of my confidence from Auntie Gracie.
Auntie Gracie looked exactly like what you think a 5-foot Italian woman who smokes a pack of Kent cigarettes a day would look like. While she was a chain smoker, surprisingly her taste buds were not burnt off, and she was an amazing cook. Her meatballs were the best in the family; the ash of a cigarette was most likely her secret ingredient, if we’re being honest.
But it wasn’t just her food that made Thanksgiving more than manageable. It was the way her tradition of hosting brought my family together (when it wasn’t tearing us apart!) and the joy and comfort I felt as a kid being surrounded by the ones I loved the most.
So, below, please find my best effort to recreate the magic and joy I felt with Auntie Gracie as a child—all traditions that we can share as a large, dysfunctional internet family! I’m now passing on to you some funny (cough traumatic cough) family stories; traditions new, old, and future; and recipes that you will want to make and others that will make you sick.
And if you’re not from the States, please enjoy this sociographic study of the American family.
XOXO,
Marco
② FUCK WITH THE CLASSICS?

A deep dive into the generational debate on changing a classic family recipe for Thanksgiving
The year was 1998, and Auntie Gracie LOVED to pick one recipe a year to change up a bit, to try something new, to feel alive again! Every year it caused light drama when someone’s favorite dish was chosen as the Thanksgiving sacrifice. So what happened in 1998? The year Auntie Gracie DESECRATED the beloved Italian Sausage Stuffing and caused the great stuffing meltdown.
Auntie Gracie’s Italian Sausage Stuffing was a beloved Thanksgiving staple…not this year. This year Auntie Gracie fell victim to Martha Stewart three days before Thanksgiving. Now, prepare yourselves, for what she made was, we believe, a cry for help…she made a Fruit Nut Stuffing. Prunes…it had prunes soaked in bourbon. PRUNES!!!
My father, Butch, calmly turned to Auntie Gracie as she unveiled her Fruit Nut Stuffing and said with a straight face, “Is there normal stuffing?”…The room fell silent; everyone was secretly wondering the same thing. After a very long pause, where I am sure Auntie Gracie was trying not to scream at my father after she had just cooked Thanksgiving dinner for two days straight, she finally said, “No, Butch, this is the ONLY stuffing I made.” The room somehow grew quieter and more tense.
Then, in one giant Italian explosion, everyone began screaming and gesturing with very strong Italian hands about how Auntie Gracie had ruined Thanksgiving by making a shitty Fruit Nut Stuffing. That Thanksgiving we all sat in silence after we had just cage-match-style fought each other over Fruit Nut Stuffing.
Finally, my father broke the silence and said, “Gracie, this is Martha Stewart’s fault, not yours. I’m sorry.”
The next year, Auntie Gracie had Italian Sausage Stuffing, and she sacrificed the green bean casserole to some weird crap with raisins, BUT she also had the classic green bean casserole that my sister Mallary loves so much. So the great debate is simple: these dishes are more than just something you love to eat. They’re dishes tied to love and nostalgia. ALWAYS keep the family classics on the table, but if Martha Stewart overcomes your body this year and you must try something new, GO FOR IT. It might become the new family favorite, or it will become a family fight. But I think we need to be smart like Auntie Gracie and always make sure both are on the table.

Do you fuck with the classics?
Uh oh, Martha Stewart has overcome my body!
③ A WORD FROM OUR SPONSOR
PAID ADVERTISEMENT*
Cranberry Radiance Facial Moisturizer
Do you ever eat canned cranberry sauce and think - it’s so good, I wish I could rub it all over my face? Well, now you…can.

That’s right - your face will glow like the gelatin ridges of that sweet Thanksgiving con-di-mont. And instead of uncomfortable political conversations, you can now talk about the jelly on your face.
*Not paid. Not real.
④ THANKSGIVING HATS

There is a canon moment we all experience when we grow up where we are sitting at a holiday table and suddenly we realize it no longer has the same magic it once had when we were children. For me, this happened in my early 20s. My siblings and I were all grown up and starting to grow our own families and juggle new in-laws’ traditions and old family traditions from childhood. For me, I was able to accept that our table would be different every year, some smaller than others, but always with someone I loved. What I had a hard time accepting was how these holidays didn’t feel magical anymore; they didn’t feel fun; they felt…silent. I think everyone was mourning change, and it was hard not to live in those feelings at the time.
So, I thought to myself, what’s something so simple, silly, and stupid? Something that will make us smile just because we look ridiculous…HATS! I am gonna make holiday-themed hats. There is no way we can sit at a table looking sad when we look like assholes. That year, I watched my family sit around a table; we each had a giant homemade paper turkey on our foreheads, and we looked like idiots. But it made us all smile, and it made us all pee our pants laughing as my mother and brother had a screaming battle in the kitchen about the turkey while dressed as turkeys. It was little, it was simple, but it helped bring back some of the magic.

Please enjoy photos of my adorable, dysfunctional family :)
So maybe you are feeling that way this Thanksgiving—you are mourning change. I have bad news. This feeling seems to happen a few times in our lives, BUT hopefully we can find the courage to look at that feeling head-on, accept it, and try to change it. Maybe that’s hats for your family, or maybe it’s printing off your favorite TV show’s Thanksgiving episode and reading it aloud over pie. And maybe nothing you try will feel right, but at least you tried, and the next holiday you try something new. We all deserve to feel the magic of the holidays at all ages, and if you are missing that feeling, then I encourage you to go searching for that magic again. Some of the best magic I have felt in life is helping others feel magic again.
If you make your own Thanksgiving hats, post them in Community or tag me on socials!
⑤ LEFTOVERS

LEFTOVERS ARE BETTER THE DAY AFTER THANKSGIVING, FIGHT ME
I am a true believer that Thanksgiving leftovers taste WAY better the next day. As a child, I wouldn’t eat a lot on Thanksgiving Day, as I knew I was fasting for the main event tomorrow: leftovers. And I still use this tactic to this day. “Does anyone want any leftovers?” is music to my ears. I am first in line; I brought my own Tupperware, in fact. Weirdly, I don’t feel this way about most food, just Thanksgiving and pizza.
Below, I have collected some of my favorite Thanksgiving leftover recipes from over the years. Unbutton your pants, Barbara. It’s a holiday. You will be skinny when you’re dead.

Click the chef’s name to access the recipe!
Leftover Thanksgiving Ring by Nicole K. Modic: OK, this is a ring you’re actually going to want to eat. Fill that bad boy with any leftovers you want and dip it in gravy!
Turkey au Poivre Pot Pie by Corre Larkin: Voulez-vous coucher avec poivre pot pie? This looked so good, and even I can’t mess up the cutting of the golden puff pastry crust.
Thanksgiving Leftovers Pizza by maze: Pizza is the ultimate form factor…so why has it taken me this long to put my Thanksgiving leftovers on it?!
Stuffing-Crust Breakfast Quiche by Derek D. Butler-Jackson: OK, a lot of French food leftover options! What can I say? I love French food! Plus, this is the perfect brunch option for once you’ve survived your family and you need to treat yo self!
Cranberry Chocolate Bites by carolinagelen: I LOVE canned cranberry sauce, and I love things covered in chocolate even more. The only thing this recipe is missing is Cher!
Thanksgiving Nachos by Spend With Pennies: FunFact™- For one of our first dates, I invited Danny to see a hockey game because I got free tickets. He replied “I’m only going to go for the nachos.” So I made matching shirts that said, “I’m just here for the nachos”. Ever since then, they’ve been a reminder of that early date. And now, they’re covered in turkey!
⑥ SPORTS!

I thank our Lord and Savior Cher EVERY DAY I was not born or married into a 5K Turkey Trot family. What do you mean, Barbara, you want me to wake up at the ass crack of dawn to RUN 3.1 miles?! You want me to wake up, RUN A 5K!?!? Come home and then cook a full Thanksgiving meal, entertain, and clean up!? What in the fresh hell?! I need the first 1–3 hours of my day to be near a bathroom just in case. You don’t have an amazing poop to start your day?! I can’t be the guy who shits himself at the Turkey Trot; it puts new meaning to the word “trot.” Also, running is horrible for your knees, and someone once told me it ages you ’cause as you run, your face is bouncing, causing you to age prematurely. If there are any doctors in the house, can we please fact-check this one?
Now, don’t get me wrong. I love what 5Ks do for charity; Turkey Trots raise millions for food banks and other organizations…hear me out. What if we did a Turkey Stroll? 5 p.m., it’s after dinner, and we are walking off the bloat. WHAT IF IT WAS A PIE-K?! It’s 5 p.m. You show up, we give you a slice of pie, and you eat and walk. Halfway through, what’s that?! Coffee and a Tums?! I’d pay for that for SURE! Am I starting a Thanksgiving PIE-K?! With all that said, I respect the sport of a 5K, but I’ll stay home and get the meal ready, and then let’s have a late-night fart walk through the garden.
⑦ BARBARAS SAY WHAT?

I asked the Barbaras what weird stuff you’re cooking up behind closed doors, and you answered! From your own gross recipes to your own stolen recipes, you’re definitely making me feel like my family isn’t the weirdest one.
Ghosty: Not a tradition but a funny story. My mother was banned from making desserts after she made a crystal lite pie. Graham cracker crust, vanilla pudding, strawberry and kiwi crystal lite mixed in. She now has been relegated to ONLY plain mashed potatoes ever since 🤣
Letitia: My favorite tradition, but my friends do not share it, is my storied catbox cake, in a new box, with a new litter scoop, and specially shaped tootsie rolls.
Also, celebrating Thank-a-ween with relatives that we normally don’t see for t-day. You know, after ‘ween and before t-day.Mandy: One year my stepmom forgot to take the gizzards out of the turkey. After that my dad took over. Also, in her family they put raisins in the stuffing. 🤢
Victoria: Ours would definitely have to be my mother in laws green sh** thats what she calls it. Its green jello with cottage cheese and some fruit idk whats all in it but its definitely good but very weird texture. She makes it every thanksgiving
Kasie: My grandma would always get “her” mashed potatoes, gravy, and mac and cheese from KFC but never told anyone. It’s a running joke in my immediate family because the four of us knew. She didn’t use spices on ANYTHING so it was a dead giveaway.
Tory: My grandma would take any left over mashed potatoes and mix it with peanut butter, roll them into balls, and dip it in melted chocolate. She called them potato dandies. Tasted exactly how you’d expect. 🤣
⑧ FROM THE ARCHIVES
Speaking of traditions, let’s not forget some of my favorite recipes of the past! If you’re joining me later on my journey, please enjoy. And if you’ve been with me for a while, please enjoy this trip…er, fall…down memory lane!




